My dear,
I should have written something to read at your memorial
service. I didn’t know where to
start. I didn’t know what to say. Martin did a bang-up job, of course. It was really beautiful. I hope somehow that you heard it, that you
saw everyone there who loved you, who each reflected a different facet of your
good life. Listen, I didn’t speak much,
but I brought flowers: two huge bouquets of roses, one red, and one red and
white. A long beautiful garland of
greens, three flameless candles, since it was in a classroom, an arrangement of
roses and greens and reds, four poinsettias.
Heather and Luke and Merry helped me carry them in and put them around
the room. It was beautiful. You would have loved to be there with the
flowers and everyone who loved you in this place, and even Pickle, all decked
out in a red and white collar. You would
have laughed at how Pickle at her memorial rose. Chomped right through it, apparently. I wouldn’t let myself cry during the
slideshow because I knew I had to speak, to read part of your baptismal
testimony, but Elspeth sobbed all the way through and Merry cried and Bea, who
doesn’t know what to do with it all, sat on my lap. And Martin cried a little, and he is not much
of a crier. And I stood up and sang the
first verse of Amazing Grace, and you would have liked that, and you would have
liked lingering afterward, and you would have liked to go for Thai food
afterward. I recognized only a few faces
in the crowd—how diverse and rich your life was—how it touched so many
people. You were something, girl. I was always so proud of you.
But the darkness was too much for us to bear or cure—and it
was too much for you to bear—and it was too deep for us to even understand. It
coexisted with your joy and your creative spirit, and I wish it could have been
vanquished. I am so sorry that it was
there. I am so sorry we couldn’t manage
to touch it much, even though we tried.
Today is your funeral.
I won’t be there, since it’s back in Pennsylvania. Martin read this great quote from Norman
McClean’s book, about how the people we love best are the people who allude us
in the end. Your life outside of us was
so full and so rich, and we didn’t know any of it, not really, even though you
told us stories sometimes. We knew you
well but in the end we realized we didn’t know you as well as we thought; the
people we love best allude us in the end.
That last week you said you were reading My Antonia. You pulled a line from the book that I had
never paid much attention to, that goes something like this, after Mr. Shermida
has killed himself: “But Mr. Shermida was not a greedy or selfish man. He was just so unhappy that he couldn’t live
anymore.” You loved that line. You were struck by how simple and
compassionate it was. You mentioned it
again on Thanksgiving, and we talked about how Willa Cather says things so
simply and compassionately. I know that
is true of you. You were not a selfish
or ugly person. You were beautiful and
loving and endlessly generous. You were
just so unhappy that you could not live anymore.
After the memorial service, I felt empty, like a sponge that
is overfull, that cannot absorb anymore.
I thought I would feel release and closure. Mostly I wanted it all undone. I wanted you to be alive again, and the last
week just a nightmare that was finally over.
On the way home I looked up at a house in Queen Anne all
sparkling and warm with Christmas lights and I allowed myself to imagine, just
briefly, that it was ten years later and you were up there, with your husband,
maybe even with a kid, and we were going to stop to say hello and to hug you
and laugh and make merry, just as we should have. Ten years.
You could have made it ten more years and then more after that, and you
would have been a powerhouse if you had been able to make it and heal. Everyone agrees that you were brilliant, and
remarkable, and funny, and honest, and full of life. Full of joy.
It was there in you coexisting with the darkness. I wish it had won on this side of life. I wish it had been able to edge out the
darkness. I am not reconciled, nor perhaps
will I or should I ever be.
I have imagined you in other places; in the train that passed
on its way up the coast; in the seagull that flew alongside the ferry on our
way home yesterday. I want to believe you are still travelling, sister, that
you are making that trip that you planned and outlined on the map.
You are still becoming; of this, I have no doubt. You are there becoming in God’s world, the
world that is not so far beyond this one.
You are potting and writing poetry and helping to set and clear the
table. You are going on walks in the
woods that you loved so much, and you are writing in tiny meticulous lines in
your journal, about all that you are learning about yourself and the world. I wish I could talk to you about it. You are mysteriously and wonderfully okay, I
know it. You are free now, but I like to
believe that you are still working, still nose to the grindstone, working in
freedom to discover every day—or however time works there—who you are, how much
you are loved.
But we miss you.
It is hard not to feel the darkness now, the darkness you
left behind. I told Elspeth that you would
not want us to think of your death, but that all you were to us in life: you drinking
tea with us, making wonderful things, curled up in a chair, writing and
reading; working in the garden alongside us, all the quiet, lovely things you
did, all the beautiful things you were.
So what do I say to you now, dear? Goodbye. I love you.
Please understand how much we loved you.
The only
one who is enough is God, and we are just broken vessels. I am sorry you were alone that last night,
and I am sorry we didn’t talk more that day, that I didn’t sit beside you and
stroke your hair and comfort you. Humans love imperfectly, and that is what we are. None of us are without regrets, though I know you would not have it so. And I know it’s not about me,
or about anyone else, but about you, and how deeply sad and ill you were. I just wish you could have gotten better. We believed you could. I wish you were not gone.
A couple weeks before you died, you told me this was one of your favorite verses, from 2nd Corinthians: So we do not lose heart. Though our outer self is wasting away, our inner self is being renewed day by day. For this light momentary affliction is preparing for us an eternal weight of glory beyond all comparison, as we look not to the things that are seen but to the things that are unseen. For the things that are seen are transient, but the things that are unseen are eternal.
A couple weeks before you died, you told me this was one of your favorite verses, from 2nd Corinthians: So we do not lose heart. Though our outer self is wasting away, our inner self is being renewed day by day. For this light momentary affliction is preparing for us an eternal weight of glory beyond all comparison, as we look not to the things that are seen but to the things that are unseen. For the things that are seen are transient, but the things that are unseen are eternal.
What is the eternal weight of glory? And how many unseen things do you see now? I told you, you are loved with an everlasting love. And you are. Rest in it now. Find peace in it now.
What do I say now? I
am sorry. I love you. I miss you.
We all miss you. All of us.
I begin the work of reframing things. Of thinking of you in life and not in death. Of letting you go. It is hard to let you go.
What did Amy write on your Facebook memorial? Now go high up on that mountain, sister. Now sing high up on that mountain.
Comments